Deuteronomy

Tigay is an outstanding whole-book commentary and an especially valuable complement to Christian treatments of Deuteronomy. He combines close attention to the Hebrew text with textual criticism, ancient Near Eastern law and culture, historical geography, and an exceptionally rich use of Jewish interpretation. Particularly valuable is his account of the arrangement of Deuteronomy 12–26 through overlapping topical and associative links rather than forcing every law into a rigid Decalogue scheme, together with his sensitivity to Moses’ rhetoric as persuasion intended to produce willing obedience. Although his historical-critical conclusions concerning dating and composition will not persuade everyone, he is commendably cautious about speculative subdivision of the received text and normally concentrates on explaining Deuteronomy as a coherent whole. One of the most informative, independent, and consistently useful commentaries available.

My personal favorite is Jeff Tigay’s JPS Torah Commentary. This commentary has all the hallmarks of a “life’s work” kind of volume. Tigay has poured his heart and soul into this piece, brought together classic commentary with the Rabbis and theologically sensitive, common sense commentary. [Full Review]

As mentioned in previous "Top 5" posts, the JPS Torah Commentaries are written by Jewish scholars and are highly technical. Tigay writes from a somewhat critical stance, so this commentary can only be recommended with qualification for discerning pastors and seminary students. Those doing scholarly work on Deuteronomy will find it immensely helpful. [Full Review]

A committed source critic studies the book within a Jewish context. [Full Review]