Gospel as Letter: A Commentary on 1 Thessalonians
Pages
406
Publisher
Fortress Press
Published
1/7/2025
ISBN-13
9798889833710
Paul's first letter to the Thessalonians enacts a historical paradigm shift by unfolding in written form that which was previously only performed orally in early Christianity. This media revolution in Christianity begins about 50 CE and will lead successively to the collection of twenty-seven writings in the New Testament. Beginning and ending characteristics of the epistle show that it is a semi-official letter from the church founders to the confessional church in Thessalonica. Since Paul stipulates that his letter should be read out in a general assembly of the congregation, artificial speech is mixed with a calculated rhetorical form--that is, narratio, propositio, argumentatio, and peroratio. The rhetorical genre of 1 Thessalonians is deliberative eulogy that seeks to encourage the community eagerly awaiting the return of Christ in their practice of the virtues of faith, love, and hope. The goal is complete holiness to prepare a befitting reception for the Parousia Christ descending from heaven.
Mell pays special attention to the ethical instructions on marriage, business relationships, sibling love, and household management made in the letter's argumentatio. Paul resolves the difficult question of how deceased church members can participate in the future, earthly salvation by inferring from the gospel itself that the resurrection of Christ ensures the resurrection of all. In this way, for the first time in early Christianity, the meaning of Christ as a mediator of salvation is unfolded so that the congregation, consisting of those who are alive and those who will become alive again, participates in the future victory of God's rule over the end-time power.
Mell pays special attention to the ethical instructions on marriage, business relationships, sibling love, and household management made in the letter's argumentatio. Paul resolves the difficult question of how deceased church members can participate in the future, earthly salvation by inferring from the gospel itself that the resurrection of Christ ensures the resurrection of all. In this way, for the first time in early Christianity, the meaning of Christ as a mediator of salvation is unfolded so that the congregation, consisting of those who are alive and those who will become alive again, participates in the future victory of God's rule over the end-time power.
Reviews
Mell’s 1 Thessalonians is learned, detailed, and often stimulating, especially in its historical, rhetorical, and socio-political observations, but its recurring weakness is overconfidence: too often a possible reconstruction is made to bear more weight than the evidence allows. He presses the differences between Acts 17 and 1 Thessalonians too hard, as though “turned from idols” excludes synagogue contact, Jewish converts, or Gentile God-fearers, when a more natural synthesis is that Paul began in the synagogue, won some Jews and synagogue-attached Gentiles, and then reached a wider pagan audience. His exclusion of 2 Thessalonians is likewise too assured, since the case against Pauline authorship remains disputed and, if 2 Thessalonians is early or authentic, it supplies important evidence about persecution, idleness, eschatological confusion, and Paul’s pastoral strategy. Several exegetical judgments are also overbuilt: his technical civic reading of symphyletai rests too much on one rare word; his treatment of 1 Thess 2:14–16 risks making Paul’s harsh prophetic polemic sound like a final anti-Jewish verdict unless held together with Paul’s Jewish identity and Romans 9–11; his wife-as-skeuos reading of 4:4 is possible but less secure than the body/self-control reading; and his Roman-imperial interpretation of “peace and security” is plausible but should not eclipse the broader Day-of-the-Lord and prophetic-apocalyptic context. The result is a commentary with real scholarly value, but one that frequently turns critical possibilities into firmer conclusions than the text warrants.
Un comentario profundo, actualizado y con una exégesis perspicaz. ¡De mis comentarios favoritos en 1 Tesalonicenses!